|
|
ADD/ADHD
The
Emotional Roots of Inattention
Attention Deficit Disorder
Understanding ADHD
Managing Your ADHD Child
| The
Emotional Roots of Inattention |
[top] |
by Barbara Frazier,
M.S.W.
Parents, teachers, daycare workers, pediatricians, camp counselors,
scout leaders, coaches, playground monitors, and anyone who has
any regular interaction with children are all acutely aware of the
growing prevalence in our culture of Attention Deficit Disorder
(ADD), and Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Certainly
the recognition of ADD and ADHD as real psycho-biological disorders
has positively impacted those children and parents who were suffering
helplessly with highly disruptive behavior and symptoms that hampered
learning, damaged relationships, and stressed families to their
breaking points. Through the implementation of medication therapy,
supportive counseling and behavior management, these families are
having some success at overcoming the problems associated with these
disorders. At the same time, as often happens with "public
advertising," the diagnoses of ADD and ADHD have become the
catch all for a myriad of child related problems, particular for
those children who are in the school system.
There are a
number of reasons why this has occurred. Part of it has to do with
the increasing tendency in our culture to overburden the educational
system with a whole host of tasks that go far beyond academic instruction.
Teachers, guidance counselors and principals find themselves intervening
in social and family problems, dealing with difficult disciplinary
challenges, and often standing in for parents as the source of emotional
guidance and support. Conversely, no one can ignore the tremendous
stress endured by parents who are struggling to meet the basic economic
needs of the family while also providing the proper amount of nurturing
and care for their children. Very often and especially in the wake
of high rates of divorce and single parenthood, these responsibilities
are overwhelming and create insurmountable obstacles that ultimately
take their toll everyone. On a larger societal basis we can see
yet another factor, which is a culture that feeds on high degrees
of stimulation whether it comes from entertainment, media, or general
activity. We find ourselves racing from one thing to another in
our work, our play, and even unfortunately often in our relationships.
It isn't really so strange that we would see an increase in hyperactive
children in a culture that seems to define itself in hyperactive
terms. What all of this means is that when we begin to examine the
problem of attention deficits and hyperactivity, we see that the
explanation, diagnosis, and solutions to such problems are quite
complex. We must carefully consider each individual separately in
terms of all the possible factors that could be contributing to
the problem before deciding a course of treatment or intervention.
Since the problem
is rather complex, I would like to discuss it over several articles
beginning in this writing with an explanation of the emotional factors
that influence attention. For continued discussion read the articles
entitled "Attention Deficit Disorder" and "Understanding
ADHD."
ORGINS OF ATTENTION
The ability
to attend is initiated very early in life during the first several
months after birth. As the new infant emerges from the safety and
warmth of the womb, he is initially assaulted with a variety of
sensory experiences as the rude light of reality descends upon him
in the labor room. In the hours, days and weeks that follow, these
sensory experiences begin to take a regular shape in the sound of
mommy's soothing voice, the warmth of her smiling gaze, or the security
of being tucked in her arms and rocked. As she makes little faces
at him, lovingly cups his feet, or coos at him, the baby is beginning
to organize his senses to take in experiences and respond to them
emotionally.
Baby's sensory
experiences, particularly those involving mommy (or his primary
caretaker) become both a means of stimulation and excitement, as
well as mechanisms for self-soothing and reaching a state of calm
(Greenspan, 1999, p. 24). Mommy's voice is very exciting when she
is making high-pitched sounds accompanied by funny faces, and is
in turn very soothing when she speaks to baby in soft, low-pitched
tones while stroking or holding him. It is this regular and predictable
interaction between mother and baby characterized by warmth and
protectiveness that supplies the infant with the first means for
attending to and harnessing the senses in ways that provide the
opportunity for learning while regulating and calming oneself. In
fact, "baby's ability to hear and respond to" mommy's
voice "is one of the primary ways in which he learns how to
take a deep breath, calm down, and pay attention to you and the
world," (p. 30). It is in the convergence and experience of
all the senses at once during the loving interactions with mommy
that baby's basic ability to attend and regulate the emotions are
established. Moreover, the basic sense of trust and security that
is built during these first few months provides the background from
which attention is derived and steadied.
Greenspan points
out that this stage in a baby's development is crucial. The absence
of loving caregivers "to help babies become interested and
engaged in the world around them" (p. 25) can prevent the achievement
of this basic sense of security, and at its worst, result in infants
that are "self-absorbed" and who lose interest in the
their surroundings. In speaking of cases of severe emotional neglect,
Greenspan reports that these infants can become so self-absorbed
that they lose muscle tone, sometimes resulting in an inability
to even move their heads (p. 25). This underscores the very important
link between emotional security and the ability to attend.
THE ELEMENTS
OF ATTENTION
Attention is
usually thought of as the ability to focus mentally in a singular
direction for a specified length of time during which other objects
of interest or focus can be put aside or kept on the periphery.
What usually is not included in the definition is the dynamic quality
of attention. It is an interactive process in which the person attending
interacts with the object of attention in such a way that there
is a reciprocal interchange. Using baby as the example, if baby
attends to mommy's face, her expressions, gaze, movements, and so
forth communicate something back to him. If mommy smiles and winks,
a feeling of warmth and receptivity is communicated which is felt
by him in the process of attending. In turn, there is a reaction
communicated back to mommy either in terms of expression, a felt
emotional response, or perhaps a return smile, squeal, or giggle.
Even with inanimate objects such as a toy or a book, the process
of attending is a dynamic one in which the words or pictures communicate
something to the child as he or she looks at the book. Or perhaps
the color and shape of the toy communicate some sense of excitement
or interest as the child picks it up, handles it, looks at it, and
so forth. Attention, then, requires a certain degree of interest
coupled with enough interactive reciprocity so that interest and
focus are maintained over time. Although the act of focusing the
mind can be considered to be a mental skill, it is the elements
of interest, interaction, and involvement that are the emotional
elements of the process without which attention could not be sustained.
Based on this
dynamic interpretation, we can make the following assertions about
attention:
- The capacity
to attend is initiated during the first three months of life as
a result of the nurturing relationship between the infant and
primary caretaker in which the sensory system is alternately stimulated
and soothed.
- Paying attention
is an interactive, dynamic process that engages and focuses the
mind in a singular direction.
- It requires
an emotional investment based on interest and motivation.
- It is enhanced
in children by a steady sense of emotional security and trust.
- It requires
the ability to calm and regulate the emotions.
- It is best
when the reciprocal feedback from the act of attending is positive.
- It is easily
interrupted by stress, emotional problems, and overstimulation.
Let's examine
the following scenario to see how these assertions play out. Sara
is a 9-year-old fourth grader who has a good relationship with her
parents, feels comfortable in her family life, and has no particular
learning disabilities. She likes puzzles and problem-solving sorts
of games, and is particularly good at math. When asked to do a timed
math quiz at school involving multiplication, she easily attends
to the task at hand, finishes before the time is up, and relishes
having her answers checked because she feels confident she will
have done well. She gets most or all of the answers correct, her
teacher gives her a big smile and tells her "good job,"
and she goes about the rest of her day with a sense of accomplishment
and contentedness. David, also a 9-year-old fourth grader, lives
with his mother (Dad left the home last year). His mother works
two jobs, is highly stressed, and David spends a good deal of time
with other caretakers along with his younger brother. He misses
his Dad, but sees him only occasionally. David also historically
has not done well with math and he has felt humiliated a number
of times when other children made fun of him during class math games.
Under the same quiz circumstances, he becomes highly anxious, fidgets
in his chair, is unable to focus on the problems, daydreams, and
doesn't finish the quiz in the allotted time. Worse yet, he gets
many or most of the problems wrong. He doesn't get the teacher's
smile, his mother isn't happy with his performance, and he is left
feeling incompetent and discontented as he moves on to his other
daily activities.
Sara's circumstances
contain all of the necessary ingredients for being able to attend
well in the above scenario. She has had and continues to have ongoing
emotional nurturing from her parents. She lives in a family and
environmental situation that is not overburdened with stress and
conflict. She has attained the capacity to focus and calm herself
when the need arises, and in this particular situation, she is involved
in an activity that is easy for her, she excels at, and from which
she receives reinforcement in terms of her competence and self worth.
She has both interest in the math games and an emotional investment
in the results she will attain from doing well. David, on the other
hand, is somewhat emotionally neglected in view of his father's
absence and his mother's inability to both support the family and
adequately attend to his needs. In fact, the fallout from the recent
marital separation is sapping both his and his mother's energy.
His ability to calm and regulate his emotions has diminished as
the stress of the separation spills over into his daily living.
Math is not his best subject and he has already learned that his
inability to perform well in this area has resulted in negative
reactions from others. For him, there is no real interest in the
subject, it isn't easy, and he is not emotionally invested in participating
as he suspects the outcome will bring negative responses and ultimately
further emotional despair. It's not surprising that David has great
difficulty in attending to the task at hand.
WHAT PARENTS
CAN DO
Extracting
from David's and Sara's situations above, it would seem that there
are certain key elements that need to be in place for a child to
be able to attend well.
- Beginning
at birth and continuing throughout childhood and adolescence,
children need a warm, loving relationship with their parents (or
parent if only one is available). This relationship begins in
the first three months as described above, and must by nurtured
continually. This means spending time with children, trying to
understand their distinctive dispositions and needs, and confirming
them as valuable family members as well as individuals. Children
who are neglected emotionally are particularly at risk for attention
problems.
- Keep stress,
overstimulation and conflict to a minimum. Family conflicts, particularly
marital problems, are highly stressful to children even if they
appear not to be directly effected. What happens is that their
emotions become tied up with the stress they are experiencing
so that they are unable to use their energy in other pursuits
such as learning. Other types of overstimulation include abuse,
yelling, too much nudity in the home, chaotic living patterns,
etc.
- Build on
strengths instead of focusing primarily on weaknesses. You want
to give equal if not more time to supporting your child's talents
and abilities. If you have a good reader, show your support by
getting a library card, making up stories together, and sharing
your pleasure in your child's interest.
- Don't ignore
deficits, but assist your child in learning how to work through
and around them. If there seems to be a problem with any particular
area of learning, get a thorough evaluation done to see if there
are some specific learning problems that need additional educational
assistance. Keep in mind that very often children who have attention
problems do not have them across the board, but only in relation
to certain kinds of situations.
- Finally,
set reasonable limits on behavior, and follow through consistently
with them. Children who have permissive parents can have attention
problems simply because they have not internalized the self-discipline
that goes hand in hand with parental limits.
________________________________________________________________________
Greenspan, Stanley I. Building Healthy Minds. Cambridge,
Massachusetts: Perseus Books, 1999.
|
| Attention
Deficit Disorder |
[top] |
|
by Barbara Frazier, M.S.W.
Attention Deficit Disorder has become a household word over the
last decade garnering the attention of parents, educators, physicians,
and child care workers not to mention talk show hosts, TV programs,
magazines, newspapers, and other such venues of public discussion.
Is it new? Not really. Most researchers agree that Attention Deficit
Disorder (ADD) has always been around, but not necessarily diagnosed,
or perhaps was recognized as some other syndrome. Whether it is
occurring more or not is hard to say. Certainly the population is
increasing allowing for greater hereditary transmission of the problem.
What is on the rise is a growing body of research into the causes,
management, and treatment of ADD that is now available to families
struggling with these problems. Likewise, there is a fair amount
of misinformation as well as contradictory information that is available.
What I propose to do here is to outline the basic symptoms and characteristics,
causes, methods for evaluation, and strategies for the management
of ADD. Since there are two major categories of ADD, I'm going to
address what is known as the Inattentive Type in this article. See
Understanding ADHD for a discussion of the specific concerns related
to the Combined Type (more commonly called ADHD) that include not
only problems related to inattention, but also hyperactivity and
impulsivity.
WHAT ADD LOOKS
LIKE
The primary
problem that characterizes the Inattentive Type of ADD is the inability
to focus one's attention. Children with this type of ADD are unable
to sustain their attention over prolonged periods of time and find
themselves easily distracted by the smallest of stimuli in the environment.
People talking, the sound of a car coming up the street, rain falling
on the roof, a dog moving quickly in the periphery of one's vision,
a stiff crease in one's pants - all of these are keenly felt by
the child with ADD, and efforts to suppress them are unsuccessful.
It is as though all of the sights, sounds, odors, and somatic (physical)
sensations flood their sensory apparatus involuntarily without the
capacity to modulate their intensity. In normal circumstances, we
may be aware of a number of stimuli in our immediate surroundings,
but we have some control on how much attention we wish to direct
toward each of them. We can keep some things in low relief while
maintaining our primary object of focus in high relief. The ADD
person simply cannot do this.
Common complaints
about ADD children are that they are dreamy, spaced out, forgetful,
careless, unable to concentrate, disorganized and distracted. If
they manage to get their homework done and in the backpack, they
can't seem to turn it in when they get to school. If you send them
to clean their rooms, you may come in hours later and find them
sitting in the middle of the floor occupied in some activity with
little to no progress made in the task at hand. If you ask what
they've been doing all this time, they may not be able to tell you
exactly. Perhaps they picked up one toy, placed it on the bedside
table, saw something that interested them for the moment, and forgot
what they were there to do. Parents of these children become extremely
frustrated with their disorganization and forgetfulness, and often
peg these kids as simply lazy. To make things more confusing, there
seem to be certain situations in which ADD children can be attentive.
This occurs when there is the element of novelty (something new
like the first week of school), a high interest value (Nintendo),
an atmosphere of intimidation (mom and dad are really mad now),
or participating in a one-on-one situation with an adult (seeing
the therapist, eating out with dad). Parents often say things like,
"he can sit in front of his Nintendo for hours" or "she
seems to be able to listen to music, and knows all the words to
her favorite songs," and so forth. At the same time, they do
poorly in school and complain about hating the work. Verbal instructions
seem to go in one ear and out the other. They lose things, don't
finish work, make careless mistakes, complain about the simplest
distractions such as a shirt that is too scratchy against their
skin.
Socially, these
kids are not a behavior problem. They are cooperative and don't
have particular difficulties with other children. If anything they
are more often overlooked and recede into the background. They may
have less interest in interacting with others and appear to hang
out on the periphery, very unlike the ADHD kids that are more "in
your face" and demanding of attention. Teachers like them and
often their problems are not detected until later in the upper elementary
years or even middle school when their difficulties with organization
and forgetfulness become very noticeable.
WHAT CAUSES
ADD?
There is some
controversy around this question, but most research points to heredity
as the most common factor. ADD children very often have a parent
who has similar problems. Conversations with these families usually
will reveal this pattern, although it is likely that the parent's
problems were never diagnosed or treated. The largest controversy
has to do with whether poor parenting can cause ADD. In the case
of true ADD, it cannot. Poor parenting can greatly aggravate the
problems and prevent the development of good coping mechanisms for
dealing with the symptoms. In fact, one of the difficulties in making
the correct diagnosis comes from our knowledge that the effects
of poor parenting, dysfunctional environmental conditions, and lack
of proper nurturing can create symptoms in children that mimic ADD.
This is especially true in regard to the behavioral components of
hyperactivity, impulsivity, and poor self-control that are the hallmark
of ADHD. This is why the evaluation process is so important. We
must determine the source of the problems by taking a full history
and then carefully evaluating the symptoms and history against the
diagnostic criteria for ADD.
EVALUATION AND
DIAGNOSIS
Diagnosis and
evaluation is difficult because there is not a specific test for
ADD. Moreover, ADD children usually do not display their symptoms
at the doctor's or therapist's office, especially during the first
several appointments as these situations have the quality of being
novel or sometimes even intimidating. Instead, the process requires
the collection of a great deal of detailed information from parents,
the school, the child, and perhaps physicians or others involved
in the child's life. Certain kinds of testing are also helpful.
I recommend starting with an extensive interview of the parents
over several appointments. At a minimum, the interview should include
a developmental history, history of symptoms related to attentiveness,
history of behavior and social interactions, and equally important,
a history of the parents' school performance and difficulties with
attentiveness if they exist. Interviews with school teachers are
quite helpful as well as reviewing school records, report cards,
behavior histories, and so forth. Psychological testing can provide
a baseline of information about IQ, basic developmental capacities,
and tendencies toward other psychological problems, but these do
not necessarily contribute much to the assessment of ADD. There
are a number of what's called "rating scales" that can
be helpful. A short list would include the Achenback Child Behavior
Checklist (CBCL), Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC),
Conners Rating Scales-Revised (CRS-R), ADD-H Comprehensive Teacher/Parent
Rating Scales (ACTeRS) and the Attention Deficit Disorder Evaluation
Scale (ADDES) series. For evaluators, Russell Barkley's Home and
School Situations Questionnaires are good devices for gathering
pertinent information from parents and teachers. These use a rating
scale to be applied to a series of questions that target ADD symptoms.
The bottom
line in making a diagnosis of ADD is to carefully collect and review
all of the information listed above, as well as spend adequate time
with the family and child for observation and discussion. It is
necessary to rule out other possibilities such as specific learning
disabilities and processing problems, depression and anxiety disorders,
or reactions to social stress either at home or school. All of these
may be present along with ADD and their careful evaluation is necessary.
ADD children can develop depression and anxiety over time, especially
as their self-esteem is challenged due to their inability to perform
and the negative reactions of others in this regard. Treatment for
these problems often accompanies the treatment for ADD.
INTERVENTION
STRATEGIES
Once the diagnosis
of ADD has been made, it is then necessary to develop a comprehensive
plan for treatment and monitoring. The plan should include the following
four elements: education and counseling, behavior management, medication
evaluation, and monitoring. Let's take them one at a time.
Education
and Counseling - Children and parents both will be able to deal
with the symptoms of ADD more effectively if they know as much as
they can about the disorder, how it manifests, and especially how
it effects both the individual and the family. A counselor is very
important in this part of the process, and can serve as the person
that oversees the process of education as well as monitors how the
family is dealing with problems as they go along. The specific issues
the counselor can address are helping the parents to devise an effective
behavior management plan, repairing negative perceptions about the
child, treatment of depression and anxiety symptoms that may have
developed among any or all of the family members, and monitoring
progress. Counseling may also be necessary to deal with marital
distress that has arisen in trying to cope with an ADD child. This
is especially true for children diagnosed with the Combined Type
of ADD where behavior problems related to hyperactivity and impulsivity
are more prevalent.
Behavior
Management - The diagnosis of ADD does not mean that irresponsible
behavior is to be excused. Rather it assists the child and family
with understanding that different kinds of strategies may be necessary
to help the ADD child function well. For example, ADD children often
do much better with written instructions, timed chores, extra positive
reinforcement, more one-on-one interaction, and structured activity.
They may also need some training in self-cueing to help them deal
with forgetfulness. Another good technique is to break tasks into
smaller components such as listing out each step of a single chore.
A counselor can help parents and children (especially teens) devise
the various strategies that will work, as well as monitor their
effectiveness in order to revise them as necessary. At the same
time, limit setting is necessary and needs to be reinforced as usual,
but with the understanding of the child's capacities. ADD children
need to get the message that they can learn to successfully cope
with their problems by identifying and understanding what they are,
and then learning how to compensate for them.
Medication
Evaluation - The most common and popular treatment strategy
is the use of stimulant medication. Stimulant medications (Ritalin,
Dexedrine, Adderall) can be quite helpful in increasing the ability
to focus, but it is very important to have a full picture of the
exact nature of the problems and their sources before plunging into
this avenue of intervention. It is not advisable to put children
on stimulant medication unless we are sure of the diagnosis, and
sometimes depending on the types of problems that are prominent,
other types of medications are indicated. In particular, children
who are having greater problems with anxiety and depression along
with ADD symptoms may do well on a regimen of what are known as
the tricyclic antidepressants (Tofranil, Norpramin, Pamelor). Sometimes
both stimulants and antidepressants are taken at the same time so
that the symptoms of anxiety and depression are alleviated while
the ability to focus is also enhanced.
Why Stimulants
Work - ADD seems to correlate with problems in the prefrontal
areas of the brain. The prefrontal cortex is associated with the
ability to focus and attend as well as self-regulate behavior and
impulses. This area of the brain is underactive in people with ADD,
and has a low level of dopamine functioning. Stimulants enhance
dopamine functioning which in turn enhances the ability to focus
and regulate behavior. Stimulants are particularly effective with
the Combined Type of ADD, and often quite effective with Inattentive
Type. They can be contraindicated when anxiety and a tendency toward
over-focusing are present. In these cases SSRI antidepressants (Prozac)
can be helpful. A word of caution is to be sure that a thorough
evaluation as described above has been completed if medication is
to be considered. Prescribing medication on the basis of a 15 to
30 minute assessment by a physician without all of the other information
is not advisable. Nor is medication treatment without counseling
and education a good strategy. Learning to cope with and compensate
for the problems associated with ADD has equal if not more importance
than simply the alleviation of attention related problems.
Is Medication
Necessary? No, not always. Behavior management programs that
are constructed to cater to the specific problems related to ADD
can greatly improve the functioning of these children, often without
medication. The decision to use medication depends on the severity
of the problems, the effectiveness of other intervention strategies,
and a clear understanding of other problems that may be contributing
to the child's overall functioning. Sometimes the treatment of anxiety
and depression along with the development of an effective behavioral
program is enough to increase the ADD child's experience of success
enough so that attention related problems can adequately be compensated
for without medication. For others, medication is necessary for
even the mundane day to day activities such as getting dressed,
brushing one's teeth, or getting to school. Each child needs to
be evaluated from the perspective of his or her own individual characteristics
and needs, family situation, and best overall strategies for creating
successes.
Monitoring
- Monitoring should take place throughout the process of evaluation
and treatment. Regular appointments with the counselor, school personnel,
and physician prescribing medication are necessary. In addition,
regular feedback between the parents with each other, and the parents
and child are also helpful in staying on top of problems as they
occur. Keep in mind that regular, positive interaction with the
ADD child is very important to enhance and preserve the parent-child
relationship, and should always outweigh time spent in dealing with
problems.
|
| Understanding
ADHD |
[top] |
|
by John P. Frazier,
M.S.W. and Barbara Frazier, M.S.W.
In our article entitled "Attention Deficit Disorder,"
we began our discussion of ADD by covering the symptoms, causes,
and treatment of the Inattentive Type. We emphasized that the primary
problem encountered by children with this type of ADD is the inability
to focus and sustain the attention. Often described as distracted,
day-dreamy, spacey, and sometimes even lazy, we also noted that
these children are for the most part cooperative, quiet, and well
liked by teachers. For this reason their problems are often not
detected until well into their school years when the problems with
inattention become very noticeable. ADHD (Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity
Disorder) children, on the other hand, are noticed early in childhood,
often in the preschool years and certainly by the time they reach
kindergarten and first grade. Why is this? Because the inability
to control one's impulses and the accompanying disruptive behavior
that are the hallmark of ADHD surface loudly and early in these
children's activities and interactions with others. Not only do
they have difficulties sustaining attention over time as do ADD
children, they have the added problems of hyperactivity and impulsivity.
Let's begin by taking a look at the three major components of ADHD
which are inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity, and then go
on to see how these affect thought processes and behavior.
INATTENTION
Like the ADD
child whose basic problem is the incapacity to focus and sustain
attention, the ADHD child has all of the same problems in attending
to schoolwork, becoming distracted, and following instructions.
In terms of school work, these children often make careless mistakes,
do not follow through on instructions, may get homework finished
(with prodding) but then not turn it in the next day, have difficulty
organizing and keeping track of school supplies, and simply forget
what they have been told. They lose things, have difficulty listening
when spoken to, and tend to avoid tasks that require sustained mental
effort. It's not so much that they are unable to pay attention or
even to understand what they are told, it's more a problem with
being able to sustain their attention long enough to translate instructions
into action. They can't seem to keep themselves from wandering mentally
toward something that is of greater interest than the task at hand.
Russell Barkley
points out most importantly that ADHD children do not have problems
with filtering information (1995, p. 30). In other words, they can
extract the important information from the irrelevant in a communication.
This means that there is not a problem with understanding what is
said. The problem is more one of distractibility, particularly when
the task at hand is lengthy, boring, repetitious, or uninteresting.
Schoolwork almost always falls into the "uninteresting and
boring" category, as do lectures from adults, instructions
that are complicated and have a number of parts, and tedious activities
that offer no immediate rewards. ADHD children attend best when
activity is interesting, novel, fun, and generates a good deal of
energy. In fact, we might go so far as to say that ADHD children
are "energy junkies." They gravitate toward highly stimulating
activities that produce sensations of excitement and emotionality.
These are usually those activities that are more action oriented
and offer immediate rewards. Also, the greater the sensory and emotional
stimulation the better. Loud music, colorful toys, big motion outside
activities, action packed video games, and so forth, offer the right
stimulation.
The last part
of the inattention problem has to do with the capacity to delay
gratification. As was mentioned above, ADHD children go for tasks
and activities that offer immediate rewards. They need something
to look forward to on almost a momentary basis. If they have to
choose between picking up three toys off the floor rewarded with
five minutes of video game time, and doing a number of jobs to earn
the money to buy a new favorite video game (at a later time), they
will almost always opt for the former. They would rather have the
immediate reward even though it has far less value both monetarily
and in terms of the pleasure it can offer over time.
HYPERACTIVITY
Inattention
is certainly a problem that is noticed in school, but more often
hyperactive behavior is what brings the note home from the teacher
asking the parents to come in for a conference. This is because
the disruptive quality of this behavior and the difficulty in managing
it requires an intensive and collaborative effort by teachers and
parents together. The hyperactivity displayed by these children
has two components worth mentioning here. The first one I would
call an overall "restlessness" that is supercharged with
energy. These kids can't stay seated in class and sometimes leave
the room without permission. They talk excessively and loudly, squirm
in their chairs, make unnecessary noises liking humming or tapping
their pencils, and so on. These are the kids you see running through
the grocery store with their mothers chasing after them in despair
as others look on with that "can't you keep your child under
control" look. Other descriptions often used are things like
"being driven by a motor", "bouncing off the walls,"
"always on the go," "can't sit still," and sometimes
simply "hyper." Normal attempts to restrict this kind
of behavior often don't work. You might hear a teacher complain
that she's moved the child to every possible seat in the classroom,
including a seat isolated from the other students, but the child
still talks to everyone and regularly disrupts the class.
The second
component has to do with being overly responsive to situations.
Barkley describes this as "behaving too much" or being
"hyperresponsive," (1995, p. 37). What he means is that
these children are quick to respond, often with a sort of high intensity
knee-jerk reaction that doesn't take into account the context of
the situation, possible rules that might apply, or consideration
of the consequences. These responses are highly emotional and forcefully
acted out without the benefit of first thinking through the situation.
Another way of understanding it is that ADHD children are very easily
emotionally aroused, and they react automatically to their heightened
feelings without first filtering them through a process of analysis.
I'll explain more about this further on in the article, but for
now lets move on to "impulsivity."
IMPULSIVITY
We've actually
already alluded to the problems with controlling impulses above.
Because of the high emotional response factor, ADHD children don't
make decisions based on objectively thinking through a situation,
but rather base decisions on their moment to moment feelings and
desires. For example, they might blurt out an answer to a question
before the question has been fully stated, or they might interrupt
others' conversations, sometimes repeatedly even though they've
been told to wait their turn. They act quickly on ideas without
considering the consequences, especially if the situation appeals
to their need for stimulation and excitement. They seem almost incapable
of waiting, and as such are quite demanding and excessive in their
drive to act. Parents complain of these children that once they
have decided they want something, they will badger them unceasingly
to get it now. If a movie is planned for the weekend, they will
do their best to get a parent to take them during the week. They
will ask repeatedly, offer a number of reasons why they need to
go now, try and manipulate the situation, coerce the parent, use
guilt if necessary, or if all else fails, whine, cry and/or throw
tantrums. The intensity and longevity of the attempts to sway parents
is what is so difficult to endure, and often wears them down until
they give in.
Impulsivity
also plays a negative role in social development. In playing with
other children, ADHD children seem unable to share, take turns,
give equal time to other children's ideas and desires, and generally
be considerate of others. They are likely to grab things out of
another child's hands, blurt out something rude or hurtful, or disrupt
activities that require delaying a response such as playing a board
game. They badger their friends in the same way they badger their
parents, and quite often are seen as selfish and annoying. Unfortunately,
most of these children want to have friends and participate as part
of the group, but they form negative relationships with other children
as a result of their pushy, disruptive behavior.
BARKLEY'S "NEW
THEORY ABOUT ADHD"
Russell Barkley
offers a unique view of ADHD that is very helpful in understanding
the mechanisms that underlie the problems of inattention, hyperactivity
and impulsivity. He believes that the real root problem is an impairment
of "behavioral inhibition," (1995, p. 43). In other words,
ADHD children do not seem to be able to inhibit their urges to "act"
in the same way as other children of a similar age can. The way
this plays out is that when the child needs to focus on or attend
to something, he is unable to inhibit his urges to shift his attention
to something that is more interesting or rewarding. It's not so
much that he has a short attention span, but he has a "short
interest span," (p. 43). Likewise, hyperactive behavior and
the tendency to impulsively act out an emotional response are again
the result of not being able to inhibit the urge to respond or gain
immediate gratification. Barkley points out that as children mature,
they naturally develop the ability to delay responses and impulses,
and to focus on instructions and activities that have low interest
value. The ADHD child does not mature in the same way and is in
fact much more like the normal younger child. Parents of ADHD children
often complain that their child seems unable to carry out the basic
age appropriate tasks that their younger children have already mastered.
If you follow these kids all the way through school and into college,
the same pattern of lagging behind developmentally seems to hold.
Dr. Barkley
expands his theory of ADHD by borrowing from Dr. Jacob Bronowski
who has a lot to tell us about how our methods of communication
are different from those of other animals, especially the primates.
In fact, a distinguishing factor between humans and primates is
the ability to "impose a delay between a signal, a message,
or an event that we experience and our reaction or response to it,"
(1995, p. 45). We can take in a message, impose a period of waiting
while we process it, and inhibit our response until we have deliberately
decided what our response should be. Further, this capacity to inhibit
the urge to respond allows us to process the message in four ways:
(1) we can split the experience or message into both the emotional
and informational components, (2) place the experience within time
by connecting it to past experiences and thereby creating a sense
of the future; (3) talk to ourselves as a means of facilitating
the process and controlling our responses; and (4) break the information
down into parts so that we can then put it back together in a new
and synthesized message with which we respond (p. 45). In short,
humans are able to stand back from an experience, analyze it, compare
it to previous experiences, foresee the consequences of different
responses, and then synthesize all of this to produce an outgoing
message or response. Moreover, it is the ability to delay and inhibit
behavior that is the starting point of the entire process. Let's
look at how each of these manifests in the behavior of ADHD children.
Separating Emotions
from Information
What's implied here is the ability to break an experience into both
its subjective and objective components. What is the personal meaning
versus the facts of the situation? Is what we are feeling actually
in response to the reality of the situation, or are we overreacting
or incorrectly assessing what is really going on? By imposing a
delay, we create some emotional space that allows our thinking capacity
to emerge and help us calmly and objectively analyze the experience
in order to formulate a proper response. Those with ADHD very often
are not able to create that space because they cannot delay or inhibit
their response. They are instead hyperresponsive to their own emotions
and tend to act (or act out) without any analysis.
Gaining a Sense of Past and Future
The ability
to delay a response slows time down in such a way that a situation
or experience can be kept actively alive in the mind long after
the event has passed (1995, p. 46). This allows us to study and
evaluate the experience, compare it to past experiences, and place
it within the context of our personal history. More importantly,
it enables us learn from our past experiences as well as hypothetically
consider our future actions. The "now" is placed in the
larger picture of personal time. People with ADHD have difficulty
in building this larger historical view. Without the capacity to
adequately delay responses, past and future get lost in the emotional
"now" driven by the need for stimulation. It's no wonder
that the same mistakes are made repeatedly, or that the payoffs
that come from long-term pursuits allude these folks. The inability
to orient oneself to the future coupled with the need for immediate
gratification can have dire results, particularly if the avenues
of stimulation and gratification become self-destructive as in the
case of school failure, substance abuse, careless driving, and so
forth.
Talking to Ourselves
to Control Behavior
When we are
able to delay responses, we allow ourselves time to talk ourselves
through the experience and examine possible responses. This kind
of self directed speech is called "internalized speech,"
(1995, p. 49). Dr. Bronowski explains that internalized speech is
different from social speech or speech used to communicate something
to someone else. Talking to ourselves, or internalized speech, is
an "instrument of reflection and exploration" (p. 49)
to hypothetically construct verbal responses. We practice how we
are going to respond by verbalizing the possibilities to ourselves
before we act on them. It has been found that ADHD children have
very little self-directed speech. In fact there are a number of
treatment programs that have focused on teaching these children
how to develop and make use of internalized speech.
Synthesizing
Information
The last skill
related to the ability to delay and inhibit behavior has to do with
the capacity to break incoming messages into smaller components
so that we can thoroughly analyze them and then recombine them into
a response that incorporates all of the aspects of our experience.
This may sound somewhat complicated, but most of us do it automatically.
We hear something, analyze it from a number of perspectives that
incorporate both the subjective and objective elements, and through
a process of synthesis we formulate a response that hits the mark
so to speak. The response takes into considerations past experience
and future possibilities, as well as the information imparted in
the present. The more successful we become at this whole process,
the better we are at problem solving. Again, all of this is dependent
on the ability to delay responses, inhibit behavior, and impose
a waiting period for processing.
THE BRAIN CONNECTION
The ability
to inhibit behavior, which is as we have determined the root problem
for those with ADHD, is facilitated in the frontal region of the
brain in an area called the orbital-frontal cortex. This is the
area of the brain that is directly linked to the capacity to sustain
attention, inhibit behavior, plan for the future, and control impulses.
It is also the area of the brain that is far more developed in humans
as compared to primates. There are a number of studies that have
linked underactivity in this area of the brain among children with
ADHD as compared to non-ADHD children. This is why stimulant medications
help. They speed up the processes in this area of the brain, and
the results are a greater ability to focus and attend, delay responses,
and control behavior. The slower brain activity might also explain
why ADHD children have such a high need for stimulation. These children
sometimes are much better able to do homework with a radio on, or
to sleep for that matter, because the stimulation from the music
actually has the effect of speeding up the functions performed in
the orbital-frontal cortex, and hence serves to calm and focus the
mind. All of this has implications for finding ways to best help
these children harness their intensity and drive toward productive
activities as well as methods to compensate for deficits. I've discussed
this more thoroughly in the article entitled "Managing Your
ADHD Child." For now, it's good to keep in mind that "stimulation"
is a key component to both understanding and assisting children
with ADHD. Any effective behavioral program will necessarily need
to incorporate the need for stimulation as a key component in developing
strategies that will work.
________________________________________________________________________
Barkley, Russell
A. Taking Charge of ADHD: The Complete, Authoritative Guide for
Parents. New York: The Guilford Press, 1995.
|
| Managing
Your ADHD Child |
[top] |
|
by Barbara Frazier, M.S.W.
To successfully
manage ADHD children, it is important to keep in mind what you have
learned about their overall strengths and weaknesses. Specifically,
we know that they have difficulties in inhibiting their responses
to events and experiences, and that their responses are often emotionally
based and without the benefit of analysis. Secondly, they have a
lot of difficulty in placing themselves and their behavioral choices
in the future, or conversely in comparing a current situation to
a past situation that is similar. This means they don't learn easily
from previous mistakes. On the good side, they have high energy
and intensity which channeled constructively can be used to assist
them in managing their behavior as well as in performing in socially
acceptable activities such as art, music, sports, and so forth.
Keeping all
of this in mind, it is necessary to develop and implement a behavioral
plan that will provide a lot of structure, uses clearly defined
rules and consequences, and offers regular incentives and rewards
that appeal to the ADHD child's need for immediate gratification
and emotional stimulation. Most important, it is also necessary
to work daily on a positive parent-child relationship that maintains
the child's sense of being loved and cared for in spite of problems
that arise. This is the cornerstone of effectively dealing with
all children, ADHD or otherwise.
Below we have
summarized some general guidelines for effectively managing the
ADHD child. Parents of non-ADHD children should also find these
guidelines to be helpful in establishing good behavior.
STOP THE EXPLANATIONS!
In trying to
get ADHD children to perform tasks (even simple ones), parents may
develop the habit of offering reasonable explanations of why things
need to be done. "You have to get dressed now because you're
going to be late for school!" "You need to brush your
teeth because you'll get cavities if you don't!" This seems
reasonable and for most children it works fine. It is helpful to
know why some things need to be done. For the ADHD child, however,
these sorts of explanations and energized warnings do not increase
compliance, and in fact over time make things worse. The negative
energy that usually emerges from the parent as these admonitions
and explanations are offered actually offer the ADHD child a reward
for his poor behavior, because the attention given feeds the need
for stimulation. So it is important to omit explanations, lectures,
verbal attempts to cajole, or even warnings about what will happen
if the child does not comply. Save the explanations for another
time when you are not in the process of enforcing a rule or request.
DON'T BE PULLED
INTO ARGUMENTS AND DEBATES
When you give
a command or make a request, there should be no further conversation.
If you have gotten into the habit of allowing your child to challenge
your requests and pulling you into debates, this will be a hard
habit to break. You simply make the request in a direct way such
as "Pick up your toys now." Don't answer questions such
as "why", or as stated above fall prey to providing explanations
when your child challenges you. Simply give the request and apply
consequences you have established previously if the request is not
followed. If you are in the habit of allowing arguments and debates,
you will need to demonstrate to your child that you will not be
pulled into arguments before trying consequences. A good technique
is to simply look at the child without reacting as he goes through
his bag of tricks to cajole you into an argument. Other techniques
are to shrug your shoulders, or walk away. Eventually when he understands
you won't play his game, he'll stop automatically.
USE INCENTIVES
AND REWARD
Remember that
ADHD children need more rewards and incentives than other children.
One of the best incentives you can offer is verbal, positive feedback
for rules followed or chores accomplished. The feedback should be
very detailed and descriptive such as "I appreciate your picking
up your toys and putting them in the toy box. Good job!" Saying
just "good job" is not enough as it doesn't reinforce
specifically what has been done, or offer the needed attention.
You can also offer physical affection, written notes, and genuine
looks of appreciation. Sometime rewards are necessary, especially
in working with problem behaviors. Rewards include things such as
extra privileges, or if using a home token or credit system, giving
points for good behavior that can be spent on privileges. A powerful
reward is your time such as playing a game together, throwing the
ball outside, etc. When giving positive feedback or rewards, be
sure to give credit for even partially correct behavior. If you
ask your child to put her clothes in the clothes hamper, and she
gets only some of them in before getting distracted, then you can
say something like "I see that you heard me say to put the
clothes in the hamper. I appreciate that you got started."
You can then request that she finish.
BREAK TASKS
DOWN INTO THEIR PARTS
In the above
example, you could break the task down into smaller parts, and then
time them while offering feedback all along the way. For example,
if there are ten pieces of clothing on the floor, request that the
child pick up five of them and set a kitchen timer for two minutes.
As soon as she makes a move to begin picking up the clothes, let
her know you see that she has started. As she gets the second or
third piece of clothing in the hamper, comment that she's halfway
done and cheer her on. If she gets done before the timer goes off,
you can praise her for beating the clock. If she doesn't finish
before the ringer goes off, praise her for whatever portion she's
completed, and then have her finish the task. The idea is to break
tasks down to the smallest component necessary to make it possible
for the child to comply, and then use reinforcement along the way
as she complies. You are training her to focus and concentrate.
Eventually, you will need to offer much less feedback while still
getting good results.
ESTABLISH CLEAR
CONSEQUENCES
Although incentives
are the primary method of establishing good behavior habits, sometimes
they are not enough. In these cases you need to apply consequences.
Natural and logical consequences work very well for most children,
however, the ADHD child does best if the consequences are simplified
and the same for most situations. I recommend sticking with time-out
as the primary consequence, especially if you set up a home token
or credit system. Sticking with time-out provides the repetition
these children need to reinforce and remember the rules. It is effective
in interrupting unwanted behavior patterns while being short enough
to maintain the necessary potency for children with short-attention
spans. It also can be applied the same way every time, making the
need for consistency easy to enact. The key is to always apply consequences
firmly, but in a neutral manner without any added negative emotion
or commentary. This leaves the child in the position of having no
alternative but to turn his attention to his own behavior (as opposed
to yours). The only other consequences recommended are those that
involve the need for reparation. If the infraction involves causing
harm to someone else, or destroying property, then in addition to
time-out you should have the child take the needed steps to repair
the situation. If he throws a baseball through the neighbor's window,
then he needs to earn the money to replace it.
ACT FIRST, TALK
LATER
Once you have
established the rules, system of incentives, and consequences, then
enforce them directly and quickly. Don't use warnings, give second
chances, or stop to explain or debate. Act swiftly and decisively
to carry out the plan you have established. Negotiating rules and
privileges is a productive strategy, but should be confined to family
meetings or strategy sessions when behavior is not in question.
Never negotiate a rule while offering a consequence.
BE CONSISTENT
Be consistent
with every facet of your behavior management program. This means
a consistent system of rewards and privileges, consistent consequences,
consistent effort in implementing the plan especially in the beginning,
and consistent responses to misbehavior. Set up your plan and don't
deviate, even when setbacks occur. Above all, if there are two parents,
they must be in agreement about the plan and both use the same methods
in its implementation.
AVOID PERSONALIZING
YOUR CHILD'S BEHAVIOR
It is very important,
particularly with difficult children, not to interpret your child's
behavior problems as a reflection of your worth as a parent. This
means not taking your child's behavior toward you personally, and
not internalizing other adults' negative evaluations of your parenting
skills. ADHD children have specific problems that are not related
to parental abilities. Others, although well intentioned, often
don't understand or buy such explanations and can actually make
things worse even as they are trying to give support. Getting professional
help can help ease this situation as well as assist you in carrying
out your plan.
SPECIAL TIME
Spending "special
time" with children is one of the most powerful tools parents
have to enhance the parent-child relationship and establish a base
from which to manage behavior. Without such a base, no behavioral
plan will work. Children must feel connected to you through love,
caring and nurturing in order to have the basic incentive to comply
with your wishes. Spending free time that is not task-oriented or
focused on discipline is necessary to foster this connection. With
children who are difficult to manage, this is even more important
due to the daily assault on the parent-child connection by negative
behavior patterns.
IDENTIFY AND ENCOURAGE STRENGTHS
It is important
to recognize and keep in mind that having ADHD is not a lifetime
curse. In fact, people with ADHD have certain strengths that not
only serve them well as they develop, but are assets that are to
be appreciated. Their drive and intensity is a resource that can
have very productive results when coupled with strong interest.
It allows them to pursue a desired direction with sustained energy
over time. Their emotionality and hyperresponsiveness are assets
in activities that require more direct response and less analysis
such as artistic pursuits, athletic activities, salesmanship, inspirational
speaking, and so forth. Parents should mentally review their ADHD
child's strengths daily. A good exercise is to make a list of everything
you like about your child including his or her potential strengths,
and place the list in place where you see it every day. Better yet,
review it at the end of the day to help balance out the day's struggles.
Take note of any small improvements. This will assist you in keeping
a big picture view and avoid getting mired down in negative thought
patterns about deficits. Enjoy your "spirited child!"
FINAL NOTE
If you have
a child that seems particularly defiant, non-compliant, and/or is
prone to becoming explosive at seemingly benign situations, then
the ideas offered in this article will not work well. These children,
who are usually diagnosed with "Oppositional Defiant Disorder,"
may also have ADHD, but the problems associated with their explosiveness
require different strategies for management. I would suggest reading
The Explosve Child by Ross W.Greene for an excellent explanation
of the problems associated with these children as well as strategies
for handling them.
|
|
 |